How to find winning cash-on-delivery products: our checklist

The 12-point checklist and 6 research steps we use to find and validate COD winning products: big TAM, one SKU, margin with air freight, proven demand.

DFDiego FuentesCo-founder, COD Confirm
Published · 8 min read

A winning cash-on-delivery product solves a common, painful problem for a very large audience, sells all year, comes in one SKU, is understood in three to four seconds and is good enough that people buy it again. On top of that, we want at least three competitors already scaling it, and we never touch impulse gadgets. That is the filter behind our stores, which did more than $300k last month.

This guide is for sellers who already run, or are about to run, COD stores in Europe and want to stop launching products that cap out at a few hundred orders. After reading it, you will have our checklist to score a product, the research steps we follow before ordering stock, and the traps we avoid.

Why does the product decide how far you can scale in COD?

COD markets are small. In the countries where we sell, not everyone shops online, not everyone is on Meta, and not everyone pays cash at the door. Each filter shrinks the audience a little more. Selling in the US is a different game: the population is big enough that a narrow product still finds buyers.

Every product has its own total addressable market (TAM): the number of people who have the problem it solves. In a small COD market, that number is your ceiling. You can do everything right, the ads, the funnel, the warehouse, and still never reach $20-30k a day, simply because the product was the wrong choice.

So the goal is to find the biggest TAM you can:

  • a problem or pain point that a large part of the population shares;
  • a product you can sell to many different avatars, with many different angles;
  • a product that sells at any time of the year, not only in one season.

An example: a product that helps with cellulite. It concerns almost every woman between 20 and 50. It is a niche, but a niche with a huge TAM, and that is exactly what we look for.

Which criteria should a COD winning product meet?

We run every candidate through this checklist. Answer yes or no for each line. Every "no" is a question you need a good answer to before you order stock.

#CriterionThe question we askWhy it matters in COD
1Big TAMDo a lot of people in our markets have this problem?Small markets cap narrow products fast
2All-year demandDoes it sell in every month?No dead season, steady scaling
3Real pain pointDoes it solve an actual problem, not a whim?The customer still wants it when the parcel arrives
4One SKUCan we sell it with no sizes and no variants?Simple stock, no stock-out on one size
5MarginLow cost, high perceived value?Pays for ads and returns
6AOVIs the order value good enough?Covers the fixed costs of every parcel
7Recurring useWill people need it again?More revenue per customer without paying Meta again
8QualityIs it good enough to be reordered?Repeat buyers, trust in the brand
9ClarityDo you get it in 3-4 seconds?No education needed on the page
10Proven demandAre at least 3 competitors scaling it right now?Demand is proven, and their ads show you what works
11Free space in COD marketsAre few or no local sellers pushing it?Small populations leave no room for many sellers
12Creative supplyAre there enough ads to keep rotating?No creative fatigue

How do we find and validate a COD product, step by step?

Step 1 — Start from what already wins in the US

We go to the US market and collect about 30 products that we know are winners, with several competitors scaling them at the moment. The US tells us what works; our job is to bring it to COD markets where nobody sells it yet.

Step 2 — Keep the top three to five

From those 30, we keep the three to five that pass the most lines of the checklist above.

Step 3 — Measure the real addressable market

For each finalist, we run deep research with Claude, covering every COD market we plan to sell in. The question is simple: how many people in these countries actually have this problem?

Step 4 — Write pros and cons

We list the pros and cons of each product side by side. It forces you to be honest about the weak points before your money is in the stock.

Step 5 — Calculate price and margin

We calculate the selling price and the margin for each product, and we check the AOV and whether there is a recurring factor. We want to know before launch that every order leaves enough money. The one we keep is the one where we are sure we will make a lot of margin.

Step 6 — Check the competition in COD markets and the ad supply

Last filter: if many sellers already push the product in COD markets, we walk away, unless we have a genuinely different way to sell it. And we make sure there are enough ads from competitors to keep a rolling stock of creatives.

How much should a COD product cost, and what margin do you need?

There is no universal rule. Nobody can tell you the selling price must be a fixed multiple of the cost. What you can afford depends on your treasury: with a lot of cash, you can buy a product at $10 and sell it at $100.

Our own preference never changes, though: the lowest possible cost and the highest possible perceived value. A product that costs $2 and sells for $30 is the ideal case.

One rule we do insist on: your cost of goods is the unit price plus air freight. Not the unit price alone. Leave the freight out and every margin you calculate is too optimistic.

Why should you sell only one SKU?

The fewer SKUs, variants and sizes you have, the simpler the business and the easier it scales. Sell a t-shirt from extra small to extra large and you need stock in every size, and a stock-out on one size blocks part of your sales. That is complex to manage.

We prefer one SKU that can reach a lot of people. If the audience is split, we split the funnel, not the product: for example, one funnel aimed at men and one aimed at women, for the same SKU.

How do repeat purchases change COD economics?

Cash on delivery is a trust problem. Customers in Eastern Europe pay at the door because they don't trust a brand they just discovered in a Meta ad. Otherwise they would pay by card.

A good-quality product changes that relationship. We know sellers who scale on recurring products this way:

  • the first order is paid in cash on delivery;
  • repeat buyers are offered card payment or a card subscription, because now they trust the brand;
  • SMS and WhatsApp flows bring them back, with card payment, a promo code or a subscription.

Every reorder is revenue you did not have to buy again on Meta. Raising lifetime value is how you make a lot of money in COD.

How fast should a customer understand the product?

In three to four seconds. On our product pages, the first product image is a short MP4 video, four or five seconds, that shows what the product does. The visitor should recognise the problem, see that the product solves the same problem as the ad, and click the order button without asking themselves questions.

We call this talking to "system one": the marketing must be immediate and intuitive, in the vocabulary your customer uses. If you have to explain or educate, you lose them.

Where do the ads come from?

We don't make our own ads at the start. That is why we require at least three competitors scaling the product: we copy their ads, translate and dub them with AI tools, and launch on Meta. Our time goes into building systems that roll a product out to more markets and more products, not into producing creatives by hand. To choose those markets, see the best cash-on-delivery markets in Europe.

Common mistakes when picking COD products

  • Going too niche. The product works, but the audience in a small COD market is too small to ever reach $20-30k a day.
  • Impulse gadgets. The TikTok gadget that lasts a few seconds, breaks easily and costs nothing. It is perceived as low value and you can never sell it at a high price.
  • Compulsive purchases. The customer buys on emotion, but the parcel can arrive two days later, when the emotion is gone. That means a very high return rate, which kills your margin. More in how to reduce your COD return rate.
  • Too few ads to copy. Without enough creatives you hit creative fatigue and stop scaling.
  • A product already crowded in COD markets. The populations are small: you compete head-on from day one. Better to find a product nobody sells there yet.
  • Forgetting air freight in the cost of goods.
  • Too many sizes and variants. More stock to manage, more stock-outs.

Your next steps

  1. List 30 products that are scaling in the US right now, each with several competitors.
  2. Score them with the 12-line checklist and keep the top three to five.
  3. Run deep research on each finalist for every market you plan to sell in.
  4. Calculate the margin with unit price plus air freight, and check AOV and recurring use.
  5. Before launching, make sure you have enough competitor ads to copy, then plan your rollout with cash on delivery in Europe, step by step.

We break this down on camera on our YouTube channel: here's how I pick products for $300k/month in Cash on Delivery.

COD Confirm

We built COD Confirm because a good product still loses money when parcels go to wrong addresses or to customers who no longer want them. It checks every address, sends every customer an SMS in their language, and our call center phones, up to three times, the customers with a doubtful address who don't respond, before anything ships. You pay per validated order, with no subscription fee. See pricing

Confirm every COD order before it ships

Address check, one SMS in the customer's language, and a call when needed. You pay only for confirmed orders.

Keep reading